wow. nike's tag/horror spot done with people who can't act.
i think this is a good lesson for any creative thinker in our business:
just 'cause you film it all low budget and put it on youtube, it doesn't make it something good.
yes one could argue that the viral did it's job by making us talk about it, and there's no such thing as negative press etc etc, but uh, all the press Nike is getting is when I utter the sentence "That Nike Spec spot blows."
it took me a while honestly, to figure out what the heck this was all about. basically they're calling the draft beer/kegger an innovative thing, just like uh, a dancing mannequin-like robot.
does anyone buy beer based on the way it is opened?
but hey, it looks cool.
my review:
The Breakup is an expertly filmed self-knowing yawn, made for the advertising community that told me exactly what i arleady know, (i.e. we don't communicate correctly to our consumers) and then leaves me with a link to a self-promotional blog. which, of course is a symptom of the problem itself: endless self-promotion.
Characters: generic advertising stereotypes. a. the 'creative' in the banana republic sweater and messed hair, self-obsessed with the same bag of tricks. b. the hot girl in the banana republic shirt.
And it's a good thing they didn't think we were smart enough to get who was who without those words strewn across their sweaters because golly i wouldn't have known without it! thanks for underestimating the advertisign community, let alone the consumers.
Also notice the important plot point left out, perhaps on the cutting room floor, that the consumer never gets a chance to actually communicate what she is looking for. just that she wasn't happy. perhaps the creatives who made the movie still don't know what she wants?
or maybe-- and this is a long stretch, but just maybe there will be a sequal this summer.
though i doubt it.
rating: 1 star out of a possible 4.
yeah it's like-- instead of giving me a real reason to buy your product you use the old 'buy us because we're not them.'
and then on topf ot that you insult half your potential target by calling them puppets.
as opposed to apple and their 'swtich' campaign. i don't remember any bill gates dolls hung in effigy...
you forgot 24: don't read litany of 'how-to's' concerning advertising. It will invariably be the same sterotypical advice that has already been said by the likes of and anyone else with a cd or ecd title who has been around long enough to feel they need to 'impart' the wisdowm.
it's almost, but not quite as bad as, the recently successful, but privately scared shitless 'owner' of a boutique shop who imparts the "get out there and start your own agency" line.
we get it: agencies suck, don't trust anyone over thirty, and don't expect to enjoy yourself. do your own thing. be a nonconformist. if all else fails, quit the job and start a magazine no one reads, dedicated to bashing your former profession.
Not to be so harsh on this posting but I have to tell you fellow ad-raggers, i am really tired of the bitterness. I have pretty much disasssociated myself from the people at work who wax poetic and spew bile in this same area all day long. the failed artists who point fingers and blame everyone else for their unhappiness. everyone else, but themselves.
call me naive-- please, i would be happy if you did-- but wouldn't it be great if just for one day we actually found something positive to say about this profession?
or if not that, let's at least take the broken record off the stereo and smash it.
ut on some twisted sister or quiet riot instead.
yes but instead you like to focus on good advertising as much as bad advertising.
and the sad part is people are talking about it as much as a crispin viral effort. except Pizza Hut doesn't like conceptual work.
but then again i gotta tell you if i were on that shoot, I don't think I'd care all that much-- "hey guys, I have a superbowl spot that's gonna suck but I got ot stare at jessica simpson up close for two days."
I think most creative men would become a hack for that opportunity, no? ;)
There is currently 1 user online.
Adland® is a commercial-laden heaven and hell for advertising addicts around the world.
This advertising publication was founded in 1996, built on beer and bravery, Adland® now boasts the largest super bowl commercials collection in the world.
Adland® survives on your donations alone. You can help us out by buying us a Ko-Fi. Adland® works best in Brave browser